Forbidden Chalice (Starlight Rare) YU-GI-OH

Shops and show vendors commonly offer about 70% of market in cash and 80% in store credit. At today's $2.95 market price that is roughly $2.06 cash or $2.36 trade for a near-mint copy. Selling it yourself on TCGplayer or eBay nets more after fees; see the seller-net answer below.

Forbidden Chalice (Starlight Rare) [1st Edition] has a TCGplayer market price of $2.95 as of 2026-11-02.

Forbidden Chalice (Starlight Rare) #RA05-EN115 is trending up: $2.95 today, up 16% in 30 days and 12% below its high of $3.36 (2026-09-16), the highest since we began tracking (2026-09-16), and 1.2x its low of $2.39 (2026-10-06). TCGplayer market price as of 2026-11-02, tracked daily since 2026-09-16. Other windows: up 3.1% over 7 days. A 30-day rise this size usually follows a supply squeeze or a new format result; check the eBay book depth before buying in.

TickerMint began tracking Yu-Gi-Oh prices on 2026-09-16, after Forbidden Chalice (Starlight Rare) came out, so these are the highest and lowest prices since we began tracking (2026-09-16), not all-time records. In TickerMint's daily data (since September 2026), the TCGplayer market price for Forbidden Chalice (Starlight Rare) [1st Edition] (all conditions) peaked at $3.36 (2026-09-16) and bottomed at $2.39 (2026-10-06).

A PSA 10 Forbidden Chalice #RA05-EN115 sells for about $51.06, based on PriceCharting's sold listings as of Nov 2, 2026. Other 10s: BGS 10 $66.00, CGC 10 $20.00, SGC 10 $31.00. A grade 9 (any grader) sells for about $15.75. An ungraded copy sells for about $3.11, so a PSA 10 sells for 16x the ungraded price. Prices from PriceCharting (pricecharting.com).

Grading Forbidden Chalice #RA05-EN115 pays only if you expect a 10: PSA 10 copies sell for about $51.06 and grade 8 copies for $12.07 (PriceCharting sold listings, Nov 2, 2026) vs $2.95 raw (TCGplayer market), and after a $25 grading fee, $10 shipping and 13% selling fees you'd need about 1 in 1 copies to grade a 10 to break even (a 80% chance). That assumes a copy that misses the 10 sells as a grade 8. Whether your copy grades a 10 depends on its centering, corners, edges and surface. Prices from PriceCharting (pricecharting.com).