Question 1

What would a card shop pay for Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art)?

Accepted Answer

Shops and show vendors commonly offer about 70% of market in cash and 80% in store credit. At today's $509.39 market price that is roughly $357 cash or $408 trade for a near-mint copy. Selling it yourself on TCGplayer or eBay nets more after fees; see the seller-net answer below.

Question 2

What is Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) (Chaos Origins) worth today?

Accepted Answer

Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) [1st Edition] has a TCGplayer market price of $509.39 as of 2026-09-17.

Question 3

What is the all-time high price for Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art)?

Accepted Answer

In TickerMint's daily data (since September 2026), the all-time high market price for Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) [1st Edition] is $516.61 (2026-09-16) and the all-time low is $509.39 (2026-09-17).

Question 4

What does Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) sell for by condition?

Accepted Answer

Recent TCGplayer completed sales for Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) [1st Edition], as of 2026-09-17: Near Mint $487.47 (82 sales in 90 days, last 2026-09-14); Lightly Played $519.99 (6 sales in 90 days, last 2026-08-23); Moderately Played $399.95 (4 sales in 90 days, last 2026-09-02); Damaged $500.00 (1 sale in 90 days, last 2026-07-14). Prices are the median of the last five plausible sales per condition, outliers excluded; conditions with no sales in the window are not listed.

Question 5

Is Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) worth grading?

Accepted Answer

PSA 10 copies of Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) are asking $820 on eBay against a raw market price of $509, a 1.61x multiple. After a $25 grading fee and 13% marketplace fees, a PSA 10 would net about $245 more than selling raw; the graded copy has to sell above $538 to beat raw. That assumes a 10; whether your copy grades a 10 depends on its condition, which is the part TickerMint's verdict weighs for members.

Question 6

What would a seller actually net for Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art)?

Accepted Answer

The TickerMint Estimate for Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) is $319.92. It is a fee-adjusted fair value blending TCGplayer and eBay data to estimate what a seller nets after marketplace fees.

TCGplayer market	$509.39	verify ↗
TCGplayer lowest ask	$460.00
eBay delivered floor (scanned 1d ago)	$319.92	the listing ↗

Magician of Dark Chaos - Black Chaos (Starlight Rare) (Extended Art) YU-GI-OH

WHERE TO BUY AND SELL

MORE FROM CHAOS ORIGINS

PRICE FAQ