NEW HERE? · 175,342 products tracked · 1,012 days of history · cited by ChatGPT
TickerMint prices every card daily from its own TCGplayer record since 2024. No black boxes.
The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 (Whispers in the Well) is worth about $15.40 today for a Cold Foil copy, the TCGplayer market price for any condition as of 2026-11-16, flat over 30 days. Non-foil copies are $5.12.
This card has 2 printings (TCGplayer market, 2026-11-16): Cold Foil $15.40 (this page), Normal $5.12 (on this page's chart).
Price trend and all-time highmore ↓less ↑
The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 is holding steady: $15.40 today, flat over 30 days and 27% below its all-time high of $21.17 (2026-07-03), but 8.8x its low of $1.76 (2025-11-07). TCGplayer market price as of 2026-11-16, tracked daily since 2025-11-07. chart →
Price data for your app or store: API with a 7-day free trial · daily history since 2024 · CSV download
Own more than this one? See what your collection is worth each day, and get an email the day a card moves 5% or more.
$0 today, then $7.99 a month. Cancel online anytime.
Cold Foil $15.40 · Normal $5.12. Which is yours?
Cold Foil · TCGplayer market · daily · any condition ↗all marketplaces ↓WORTH GRADING?
WHERE TO BUY AND SELL
Cold Foil · eBay scanned Nov 17A plain answer from this card's real sales numbers. No guesses. Part of Premium: 5 questions a day.
GAME DATA[ + ] SHOW[ × ] HIDE
- INKTYPE
- Ruby
- CARD TYPE
- Character
- COST INK
- 5
- PROPERTY
- The Legend of Sleepy Hollow
- STRENGTH
- 4
- WILLPOWER
- 2
- LORE VALUE
- 2
- DESCRIPTION
- [Leaves No Trace] When you play this character, banish chosen opposing character with 2 Strength or less. [Gathering Strength] During your turn, whenever an opposing character is banished, each of your characters gets +1 Strength this turn.
- CLASSIFICATION
- Storyborn;Villain
- CHARACTER VERSION
- Terror of Sleepy Hollow
- INKWELLICONONCARD
- No
MORE FROM WHISPERS IN THE WELL
FULL SET →PRICE FAQ
Why does The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 have two prices?
+×
The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 was printed 2 ways and each one sells separately: Cold Foil $15.40; Normal $5.12 (TCGplayer market, 2026-11-16). Check the set, the rarity mark and any parallel foil, manga art or edition stamp on your copy to know which price is yours; TickerMint prices every printing on its own page.
What would a card shop pay for The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow?
+×
As a rule of thumb, shops and show vendors pay about 70% of the market price in cash and about 80% in store credit for a near-mint copy, because they need room to resell it. At today's $15.40 market price that is about $10.78 in cash or $12.32 in store credit. It is a rule of thumb, not a quote: each shop sets its own offer. Selling it yourself on eBay or TCGplayer usually leaves you more after fees, and takes longer.
What is The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Whispers in the Well) worth today?
+×
The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow [Cold Foil] has a TCGplayer market price of $15.40 as of 2026-11-16. Non-foil copies are $5.12.
Is The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow going up or down in price?
+×
The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 is holding steady: $15.40 today, flat over 30 days and 27% below its all-time high of $21.17 (2026-07-03), but 8.8x its low of $1.76 (2025-11-07). TCGplayer market price as of 2026-11-16, tracked daily since 2025-11-07. Other windows: up 0.0% over 7 days, down 22.5% over 90 days, up 22.3% over a year.
What is the all-time high price for The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow?
+×
In TickerMint's daily data (since November 2025), the TCGplayer market price for The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow [Cold Foil] (all conditions) peaked at $21.17 (2026-07-03) and bottomed at $1.76 (2025-11-07).
DISCUSSION
LOG IN to join the discussion.
What's your read on this card? Start the thread.
Get the weekly deep dive by email → one email a week, the cards and artists moving the market





