NIGHTMARE MAGICIAN CARDS BY PRICE
The most expensive Nightmare Magician card right now is Nightmare Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) (Duelist Nexus) at $11, ahead of Nightmare Magician ($1) and Nightmare Magician ($1). TCGplayer market price for raw near-mint copies, refreshed daily.
EVERY NIGHTMARE MAGICIAN CARD · BY MARKET PRICE
| # | CARD | MARKET |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Nightmare Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) | $10.77 |
| 2 |  Nightmare Magician | $0.77 |
| 3 |  Nightmare Magician | $0.75 |
| 4 |  Nightmare Magician (Super Rare) | $0.23 |
| 5 |  Nightmare Magician | $0.12 |
Every English printing of Nightmare Magician in the catalog with a price, valued at its priciest usable printing.Grouped by the character name at the front of each product title. All Yu-Gi-Oh! characters →
FAQ
What is the most expensive Nightmare Magician card?
+×
As of 2026-09-17, the most expensive Nightmare Magician card by TCGplayer market price is Nightmare Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) (Duelist Nexus) at $11. Next: 2. Nightmare Magician (25th Anniversary Tin: Dueling Mirrors) $1, 3. Nightmare Magician (Duelist Nexus) $1, 4. Nightmare Magician (Super Rare) (Phantom Revenge) $0, 5. Nightmare Magician (Phantom Revenge) $0. Raw near-mint prices; graded copies trade higher.
How many Nightmare Magician cards are there?
+×
TickerMint tracks 5 priced English Nightmare Magician cards (every printing counted once at its priciest version), worth $13 combined today. The cheapest Nightmare Magician card worth at least a dollar is Nightmare Magician (Quarter Century Secret Rare) (Duelist Nexus) at $10.77.
Are Nightmare Magician cards going up in value?
+×
Each card page shows the 7, 30, 90 and 365 day moves for that printing. The Nightmare Magician list here is today's snapshot; open the top card for its history and whether it is near an all-time high.